Go Dogs wrote:
Bumpyroad wrote:
and is there really any difference in boiling a steak at 125, 130, or 135? in any event you must slap it on a skillet/grill/etc. to make it palatable. I think instead of water it would be tastier to just marinate it for the same length of time.
bumpy
You better look up the temp of boiling water. Sous Vide is not about 'boiling'. The water is a source of gentle heat, the food does not come in contact with it. However, if you know more about this subject than the people that have actual experience with it- we will have to bow to you.
some interesting tidbits from a web search.
Safety
Food safety is a function of both time and temperature; a temperature usually considered insufficient to render food safe may be perfectly safe if maintained for long enough. Some sous-vide recipes such as fish are cooked below 55 °C (131 °F). However, pasteurization of the food to be eaten by people with compromised immunity is highly desirable. Women eating food cooked sous-vide while pregnant may expose risk to themselves and/or their fetus and thus may choose to avoid unpasteurized recipes.
Clostridium botulinum bacteria can grow in food in the absence of oxygen and produce the deadly botulinum toxin, so sous-vide cooking must be performed under carefully controlled conditions to avoid botulism poisoning. Generally speaking, food that is heated and served within four hours is considered safe, but meat that is cooked for longer to tenderize must reach a temperature of at least 55 °C (131 °F) within four hours and then be kept there for sufficient time, in order to pasteurize the meat.
Pasteurization kills the botulism bacteria, but the possibility of hardy botulism spores surviving and reactivating once cool remains a concern as with many preserved foods, however processed. For that reason, Baldwin's treatise specifies precise chilling requirements for "cook-chill", so that the botulism spores do not have the opportunity to grow or propagate. Pasteurised food can then be stored for up to two weeks at around 3 °C (37 °F) sealed within the vacuum pack.
The plastic used must not leach endocrine disruptors. Many plasticizers used in plastics have these properties.[13][14]
that document also pointed out that steak cooked in this fashion sucked.
I note elsewhere in the web that the temperatures for meat should be 145-165 or thereabouts.
also that the temperature is not all that critical for this method of food preparation.
Of course this isn't the only place where the French have messed up cooking food.
liked your other post/thread incidentally.
regards,
bumpy