Forum Discussion

sonuvabug's avatar
sonuvabug
Explorer
Apr 03, 2022

Recommendations for replacing my Michelin LTX M&S tires

It's time to replace my 9 year old LT265/75R16 Michelin LTX - M&S tires. These have served me well for 9 years and I could easily replace them with a new set of LT Defenders and be done with it.

However, I know new tires, designs and compounds come out every year and before I commit to another tire, I am interested in other brands and models to research. I am not willing to jump into a 19.5" set-up, nor do I want an A/T or mud tires. I am happy with a HT (highway tire) in the OEM size listed above.

I also do not want a "budget/good enough" tire. My TC set-up is heavy and I also pull a 3,500 lb. enclosed cargo trailer behind me. Safety is an important consideration for me. On price, I don't mind spending good money if the corresponding value and quality is there. My current Michelins have served me very well. I just wish I could have gotten more use out of them before they aged out.

One concern I do have with the Defenders which replace the LTX's is that I'm reading they can get soft and squishy in the summer and road heat. We run the new P-metric Defenders on our 2011 RAV4 I've never experience any jelly like ride performance feeling with the RAV.

Nobody is interested in a tire flame fest here. What I am looking for are some informed opinions and recommendations based on your own, first hand experiences. Thanks in advance folks.
  • We've run on BFG AT tires for years. We carry a 3200 lbs Truck Camper, and often towed a 3200 lbs cargo/bike trailer. We've never had trouble in all those years. Well, shouldn't say never, one time had a glitch in one rear tire after a few years wear. BFG replaced two tires in rear, so we'd have same wear on both rear tires. BFG did in fact, deduct a bit for tire wear - but we were happy with that response.

    We run LT285-70-R17E ... 75 lbs in rear, 70 lbs in front when loaded and hauling.
  • sonuvabug wrote:
    specta wrote:
    Michelin Agilis Cross Climate


    These caught my eye previously until I researched on Michelin's .ca website that they are only rated at 1550 lbs @ 80 psi. Can't figure that out for a LT tire in my size unless it is an error.


    I would have to think its a typo.

    I had LT 265/70R17 and they were rated 3195 @ 80 psi.

    I recently bought some Toyo tires because I stepped up to 18" wheels and Michelin didn't make them in the size I wanted.

    Agilis cross climate are excellent tires.
  • specta wrote:
    Michelin Agilis Cross Climate


    These caught my eye previously until I researched on Michelin's .ca website that they are only rated at 1550 lbs @ 80 psi. Can't figure that out for a LT tire in my size unless it is an error.