westend wrote:
I wouldn't agree that the RV SCD receptacles are better than a typical residential duplex sold at the big box stores. The SCD receptacles are prone to bad or loosened connections and aren't built with nearly the durability of a standard receptacle.
Also, advocating bad wiring practices (like the elimination of an enclosure) is just not good. There's enough that can go wrong besides trying to use shortcuts.
Who said something about eliminating an enclosure? Or that they are better? The SCD devices have an integral cover on the rear of them. As an EE, I see absolutely nothing wrong with SCD devices. They are identical to what's used in mobile homes, and there must be millions of those out there without issue. SCD devices, like other electrical devices and components must pass rigorous testing by testing organizations like UL or CSA, the same as residential receptacles. SCD wiring devices are designed and approved for use in RVs - that's what they're for.
The problem with SCD devices, and it does happen at RV plants also, is that the wires can be improperly terminated onto the push-in terminals, either by lack of using the correct tool or by carelessness. There's nothing inherently bad about SCD devices, it's about how they are installed. There's a lot of folks who shouldn't be doing 120 volt wiring in RVs or houses. Even licensed electricians do things like wire up a 120 volt RV for 240 volts. The very
first SCD receptacle I pulled out of our first TT did not have the wires properly terminated, with the wires only pushed onto one of the two connectors. With a full 15 amps being drawn through it, it could have possibly overheated.
Like a lot of things, read the instructions, and if you need more help, go on the internet or ask somebody and make sure it's installed correctly.
One major advantage of SCD devices is that they are smaller overall and will fit in shallow cavities. They're also faster to install. There's nothing wrong with installing a residential type outlet box and recept. (or switch) in an RV, as long as it's not in an exterior wall and is installed properly. But doing this just because someone thinks that SCDs are bad is wrong. If there is anything from credible trade organizations, electrical inspectors or electrical manufacturers outlining problems, I'm curious and I'd be interested in seeing links to them.
This photo shows the cover on the rear of an SCD receptacle which covers exposed wiring and parts. I just bought 5 of these to replace white ones in our TT. I just can't see why there'd be an issue with the device itself.