Forum Discussion

Mike_P_'s avatar
Mike_P_
Explorer
Oct 21, 2016

Winnie Questions

Will be seriously looking at used motorhomes this winter in AZ.
A Winnebago pusher will be on my short list, 2004-2007 36-38 foot.
I read a lot about roof problems and slide problems with the later models.
I also wonder about noise while sleeping from the air conditioner under the bed so to speak.
While I know each manufacturer has its own problems, should I eliminate Winnie from my list?
Newmar and Monaco are my other choices.
Thanks for any and all stories and suggestions.
Mike
  • Mile High wrote:
    We have the rooftop Mach 8 low profile ACs and they are terrible noisy (my chief complaint on the whole rig). It's not the airflow, they are just mechanically noisy on the roof. I've done the fan upgrade but that just made the outside somewhat quieter. My previous Dometic Briskair's were far quieter.


    Agree on the newer Mach 8. My coach has 3 15K Coleman heat pumps and the front unit failed last year. It was replaced with the new Coleman Mach 8 and it is louder inside and out than the older units. I believe the fan runs faster due to the unit being more low profile with smaller coils, plus it is made more cheaply than the older units. Thus, more noise.
  • I have a 97 Winnebago Luxor. The high end for them at that time. My basement a/c has never failed in all these years. It is under the couch behind the drivers seat and you can't hear it in the back while sleeping. I got it used 15 years ago and it has several options that I don't see on new ones today that I took for granted until I started looking for a newer unit.
  • ferndaleflyer wrote:
    I have a 97 Winnebago Luxor. The high end for them at that time. My basement a/c has never failed in all these years. It is under the couch behind the drivers seat and you can't hear it in the back while sleeping. I got it used 15 years ago and it has several options that I don't see on new ones today that I took for granted until I started looking for a newer unit.


    Just curious what does it have that new ones don't. And before some wise guy comes along payments don't count. :B
  • Mile High wrote:
    We have the rooftop Mach 8 low profile ACs and they are terrible noisy (my chief complaint on the whole rig). It's not the airflow, they are just mechanically noisy on the roof. I've done the fan upgrade but that just made the outside somewhat quieter. My previous Dometic Briskair's were far quieter.


    Do your units have the original 6 blade fan? If so they can be upgraded to the new and much quieter 3 blade fans. The 3 blade design moves more air and is considerably more quiet that the 6 blade one.

    The part number for the upgraded fan kit is 1472D5041. It includes a 3 blade fan and a bracket. The bracket keeps the exterior shroud from collapsing on the fan blade. If you get new fans be sure they are revision D. They had some others out before this revision that would self destruct.

    I called the AIREXCEL technical hotline for another problem and they sent me 2 of these kits at no charge.
  • Hikerdogs wrote:
    Mile High wrote:
    We have the rooftop Mach 8 low profile ACs and they are terrible noisy (my chief complaint on the whole rig). It's not the airflow, they are just mechanically noisy on the roof. I've done the fan upgrade but that just made the outside somewhat quieter. My previous Dometic Briskair's were far quieter.


    Do your units have the original 6 blade fan? If so they can be upgraded to the new and much quieter 3 blade fans. The 3 blade design moves more air and is considerably more quiet that the 6 blade one.

    The part number for the upgraded fan kit is 1472D5041. It includes a 3 blade fan and a bracket. The bracket keeps the exterior shroud from collapsing on the fan blade. If you get new fans be sure they are revision D. They had some others out before this revision that would self destruct.

    I called the AIREXCEL technical hotline for another problem and they sent me 2 of these kits at no charge.


    I did install the D version of the upgraded 3 blade fans based on an earlier post you helped me with in May - Thank you!

    The replacement fans truly kicked down a lot of the noise on the outside of the unit, and almost changed the tone to a turbine sound which is also a bit annoying :) I told my daughter it sounds like the rooftop of an industrial building up there, but overall it truly is quieter outside and more considerate for the neighbors.

    As far as the interior noise, I didn't notice any kind of change in the noise. It is more of a rumbling noise that air, maybe vibrating through the roof, but they are terrible. If have half a mind to replace all three with the standard height ACs like I used to have.

    I will say- when all three of these are running through that single duct, it will blow the sheets off the bed! OK, part my hair anyway :)
  • In the year of coach your talking about Winnebago used HWH Slides most slide problems in the Winnebago started around 2012. As far as basement air goes it doesn't bother me but, it bothers my wife. So we use a little potable heater at night.