Forum Discussion

BPRescue's avatar
BPRescue
Explorer
Aug 09, 2017

Negotiating TT price - adding a TT to the fleet.

Hi All.
I guess this will be long... Sorry, I can be chatty sometimes...

I have been considering adding to the fleet for a few years, and now getting ready to pull the trigger. I have a PUP with a boat loader for my aluminum boat which gets me wherever I want to go in terms of terrain, so I can get well away from the crowds, setup off grade, etc. It does take time to setup, including prep where I have to open it pre trip, so it has hindered many quick weekend trips, or even long trips where facilities would be nice. So, I have been looking to expand and while you will never get a TT where I go with the PUP, I still plan on doing the boondocking thing on the endless primitive roads here is AZ. I will clearly visit more campgrounds, including the full hookup thing as well, but I don't want to be limited and desire something that can handle fairly rough dirt roads.

This summer I decided to do a test run on a TT and rented a 2016 Jayco 23MBH for 10 days in Jackson and Yellowstone. I did the full hookup thing, as well as boondocking. My 2015 Tundra towed it beautifully and it did not feel much different than my boat in terms of length. I have a TRD Pro, so even with the equalizer, I did see some dip and will invest in air bags. But, this TT passed all my tests with flying colors and where I understand it will limit my true backcountry sites, I won't be limited to just pavement or nice graded gravel roads either.

I have narrowed my choices down to 2 TT's which are both at the top of my limit in 23' model length (for navigability). The first is the Jayco Jay Feather 23BHM, and the second is the Outdoors RV Black Rock 23BKS with the off road package. BTW, we also have two kids, so the bunk beds are perfect as well and the kids love them.

For the Jayco, both my wife and I like the floor plan. I don't know the reason, but they changed it a bit from the 23MBH I rented with a few items being the orientation of the toilet, no sunroof in the living area, and lack of windows on the side of the slide out. Storage is very limited on this, especially if I integrate the boat, or add an inflatable, but it is doable. She likes this better than the Outdoors RV because the vanity is outside the bathroom, and the Murphy bed allows extra usable space up or down. The negative for me other than the small items I mentioned is the smaller water tanks, and it is not as tough as the Outdoors RV, including the beefed up suspension, frame and build.

The Outdoors RV while I have not met one in person yet, appears to be a much stronger build with the off road suspension, frame and wall construction. The cabinets are better as well with pocket holes rather than staples. (though I don't know if that means the cabinet frames, or boxes themselves, so I will need to verify when I see them in person). I like the floor plan and while the bed is permanent, the wall will likely remove that "great room" type feel my wife likes. I think I like the materials are better, but we will see, when I "see" it in person. The wife does not like the floorplan as much as the Jayco, with the vanity being a big part of that. For me though, this thing adds many bonus points because of it's build. The frame is stronger, suspension allows for more travel with shocks, better ratings on the tires, larger tanks, better insulation, storage, etc. Again without seeing it, this is my favorite based on its capabilities off the beaten path, though I don't like that it is almost a foot taller. If I do consider designing a boat loader for my aluminum like I did on my PUP, that extra height might be an issue. I may consider a nice inflatable though, which reminds me there is much more storage on the Outdoors RV. This is a little heavier than the Jayco, but both are within my tow limits on the Tundra including payload of passengers, tongue weight, etc.

Anyway, my real question here is on how to negotiate price on these. In the last 25 years, I have only paid above invoice for two vehicles being an M3, and my TRD Pro. Both were highly sought after and I had the M3 built as a surprise Xmas gift for my wife, so there was not as much wiggle room as normal. Regardless, in danger of retaining my modesty, I have mastered negotiations on vehicles where I always get a very good deal. At the same time, invoice pricing, holdback and other info is readily available on the internet, so it's just a matter of brining in the laptop with all data gathered, supportin documentation printed, and letting the dealership know if they won't give me the price I know they can, I will go to another dealer. Nowadays I have moved onto fleet sales as that is much easier. Anyway, this is a little different being it's a camper and my last experience was over 15 years ago. The Jayco has just a few dealers in my state, and the Outdoors RV just one. So, I lose a little power there. I may increase it a bit because even if I decide the Outdoors RV, they will think they are pitted against the Jayco with the lower price point, and of course I won't really care about the stronger components of the Outdoors RV. :) Just like a car, they will think I can easily do without it...

That said, what are you guys seeing on negotiations? Where does the power come from? Is there accurate invoice pricing available? We are at the end of model year here, so that will help, but I would like a better grip than that...

Thanks all.
  • Sounds like u know already how to play the game and play it well. And are just looking for bottom line help on the model u want. I found these 23bks models on rv trader if it helps for comparison. I like playing the game to and have no problem walking out the door.

    https://www.rvtrader.com/New-And-Used-Outdoors-Rv-Black-Rock-23BKS-Travel-Trailer-For-Sale-On-RV-Trader/search-results?category=Travel%20Trailer&sort=featured%3Aasc&radius=150&layoutView=listView&make=Outdoors%20Rv&model=Black%20Rock%2023BKS&
  • BadgerMcAdams wrote:
    Mike Up wrote:
    Ralph Cramden wrote:
    jim1521 wrote:
    Here you go....

    Dealer Invoice



    That link is not a very accurate source. If it is I did pretty good by paying over $3K less than the dealers invoice on our 2017 Rockwood.

    I did a lot of research and requested a lot of quotes online to order our current unit. Then I simply called the closest dealer for the brand, told them what I wanted and was willing to pay. It was very much a take it or leave it proposition. They took it and I don't think I left much on the table if anything. Get a quote from RVW or some of the other self proclaimed wholesalers if they carry the brand. In reality they are just dealers the same as any other dealer. Plenty of other dealers in the same geographical market will match and often beat their prices.


    Agreed, the dealer cost seems really high compared to what people are actually paying.


    That's how the dealer makes you THINK you are getting something over on them ;)


    And its amazing how many people take the bait.

    "Special Show pricing" = At least $1K more than I could of purchased for from off the dealers lot. Someone pays for floor space at the expo or convention center and its not cheap. Its not the dealer who pays for it.

    "MSRP" = One is born every minute, here comes one now, lets see if we can get him to pay MSRP or close to it. Better yet lets print out a fake invoice with an MSRP we pulled from thin air, and let it lay in the trailer. We can also plaster it all over the net.

    "Dealer Invoice" = Harder to get info than the access code to the nuclear football. Hint...take the accurate MSRP as reported by the manufacturer, if you can find it. Deduct 30% then deduct another 25% from that number. You're now in the ballpark within 5% one way or the other.

    Our 2017 Rockwood Roo with options was listed at $31K by Rockwood. We paid $19K out the door, a straight cash deal with no trade. I have met three other 23WS owners at the campground. None had as many factory options. Two were purchased from the same dealer. They paid $24K, $25.5K, and the third who purchased from RVW paid 22K plus took the hit with their financing arrangement that their price is always dependent on.
  • As with any negotiation, you have a price figure you cannot exceed. They have a price figure they cannot go under. Take their sale price, offer $20,000 less, see what they say! Yea, its a game, tit-for-tat, back and forth. When they exceed your highest, you simply walk. If they come in below your highest amount, take it! The secret is to not be afraid to walk out during negotiations, and stick to it.
  • Mike Up wrote:
    Ralph Cramden wrote:
    jim1521 wrote:
    Here you go....

    Dealer Invoice



    That link is not a very accurate source. If it is I did pretty good by paying over $3K less than the dealers invoice on our 2017 Rockwood.

    I did a lot of research and requested a lot of quotes online to order our current unit. Then I simply called the closest dealer for the brand, told them what I wanted and was willing to pay. It was very much a take it or leave it proposition. They took it and I don't think I left much on the table if anything. Get a quote from RVW or some of the other self proclaimed wholesalers if they carry the brand. In reality they are just dealers the same as any other dealer. Plenty of other dealers in the same geographical market will match and often beat their prices.


    Agreed, the dealer cost seems really high compared to what people are actually paying.


    That's how the dealer makes you THINK you are getting something over on them ;)
  • Ralph Cramden wrote:
    jim1521 wrote:
    Here you go....

    Dealer Invoice



    That link is not a very accurate source. If it is I did pretty good by paying over $3K less than the dealers invoice on our 2017 Rockwood.

    I did a lot of research and requested a lot of quotes online to order our current unit. Then I simply called the closest dealer for the brand, told them what I wanted and was willing to pay. It was very much a take it or leave it proposition. They took it and I don't think I left much on the table if anything. Get a quote from RVW or some of the other self proclaimed wholesalers if they carry the brand. In reality they are just dealers the same as any other dealer. Plenty of other dealers in the same geographical market will match and often beat their prices.


    Agreed, the dealer cost seems really high compared to what people are actually paying.
  • jim1521 wrote:
    Here you go....

    Dealer Invoice


    Wow my dealer cost on a 26BH went up by over $5k in just 5 years. That seems really excessive.
  • jim1521 wrote:
    Here you go....

    Dealer Invoice



    That link is not a very accurate source. If it is I did pretty good by paying over $3K less than the dealers invoice on our 2017 Rockwood.

    I did a lot of research and requested a lot of quotes online to order our current unit. Then I simply called the closest dealer for the brand, told them what I wanted and was willing to pay. It was very much a take it or leave it proposition. They took it and I don't think I left much on the table if anything. Get a quote from RVW or some of the other self proclaimed wholesalers if they carry the brand. In reality they are just dealers the same as any other dealer. Plenty of other dealers in the same geographical market will match and often beat their prices.
  • "Where does the power come from?"

    Putting a cashier's check on the table between you and the sales person and/or his/her manager, and being able to take the check back and walk out.