Forum Discussion

BobsYourUncle's avatar
Aug 02, 2020

Need input into newer GM D/A dually trucks

I am considering replacing my truck, it is getting old with over 403,000 K on the odometer. Reliability is waning a bit, stuff starting to break. (Truck in sig)
A lot of people say keep and fix it, as the LBZ was the best. But a vehicle gets to a point where things just start wearing out.

My old beast has been good, but 14 years as a dedicated work truck has taken its toll, even though I try to take care of it.

Are there any inherent problems with later model GM Duramax/Allison trucks? Any ones in the 2016 - 18 range I should be wary of? Any to stay away from?

I know the DEF system is a pain in the rear, but what about other issues?

I found a nice clean 2016 3500 D/A dually, loaded. 160,000 K on the odometer. I haven't contacted the seller yet, want to do my homework first. It is half the price of a new truck. 48G sticker.

Still astounds my how much used trucks go for....:E

Thanks. :)

10 Replies

  • If you can delete it, a LMM, low miles would be great, and even not bad with emissions if you work the truck.
    LMLs have the cp4 pump. Personally I’d put a disaster kit on a cp4 and replace with a cp3 if the cp4 died.
    L5P trucks are the best (and most expensive) answer, short of finding a low mile LBZ, imo.
  • KD4UPL wrote:
    The Duramax used thru 2016 was the LML. In 2017 they started with a new Duramax called the L5P. The L5P uses a Denso fuel system instead of a Bosch system. The old Bosch CP4 injection pump had a bad reputation for failures on both Chevy and Ford diesels. When the pump went out it generally took the rest of the fuel system with it. I would much prefer a 2017 or newer with the Denso pump. The L5P also gained 80 hp and 250 lb ft.


    This is one of the reasons I traded in my 2012 Duramax last fall with about 109K on it. While it was a good truck I knew it had the CP4 in it and it was a potential ticking time bomb. The other reason is I didn't want the first year of a redesign of the 2020's not to mention the look especially the Chevy's are controversial, plus deals were to be had on the 2019's last fall. I agree with the 2017-2019 model years is where I would shop.

    Dan
  • 2019 is the LAST year of the true Allison 6 speed transmission ( unless you get a 4500 of bigger) as they went to the new 10 speed in 2020 ( built by GM but “ branded” Allison )... Got a 2019 Duramax Dually for hauling our AF TC on ( we’re FT ) ....Not a complaint in 23000 miles...
  • KD4UPL wrote:
    The Duramax used thru 2016 was the LML. In 2017 they started with a new Duramax called the L5P. The L5P uses a Denso fuel system instead of a Bosch system. The old Bosch CP4 injection pump had a bad reputation for failures on both Chevy and Ford diesels. When the pump went out it generally took the rest of the fuel system with it. I would much prefer a 2017 or newer with the Denso pump. The L5P also gained 80 hp and 250 lb ft.
    I am also astounded at the kind of money people pay for trucks. I've been shopping for a new work truck myself as my 2005 that I bought new now has 270,000 miles on it. Mine is still doing quite well but I know I'll need a new one before long.
    When I build a crew cab diesel dually cab and chassis truck with 4wd exactly like I want it the sticker is about $56,000. The price from the dealer is around $49,000. When I look at used trucks the majority of them 5 years old or so are going for more than I can buy a new one for. I can't for the life of me figure out what you add to a truck that's worth an extra $30,000 over what I'm specifying.

    That's good to know about the pump, thanks. Good information. I had to put a pump on mine at around 300,000K. Expensive...
    The price difference Canada vs US is a lot. I built one last year similar to mine, a few more options but not everything and it was 84G Cdn. Hard to justify.
    Boggles my mind the price of used trucks.
  • The Duramax used thru 2016 was the LML. In 2017 they started with a new Duramax called the L5P. The L5P uses a Denso fuel system instead of a Bosch system. The old Bosch CP4 injection pump had a bad reputation for failures on both Chevy and Ford diesels. When the pump went out it generally took the rest of the fuel system with it. I would much prefer a 2017 or newer with the Denso pump. The L5P also gained 80 hp and 250 lb ft.
    I am also astounded at the kind of money people pay for trucks. I've been shopping for a new work truck myself as my 2005 that I bought new now has 270,000 miles on it. Mine is still doing quite well but I know I'll need a new one before long.
    When I build a crew cab diesel dually cab and chassis truck with 4wd exactly like I want it the sticker is about $56,000. The price from the dealer is around $49,000. When I look at used trucks the majority of them 5 years old or so are going for more than I can buy a new one for. I can't for the life of me figure out what you add to a truck that's worth an extra $30,000 over what I'm specifying.
  • Walaby wrote:
    BobsYourUncle wrote:
    jdc1 wrote:
    40,000+ snip

    No, snip

    Think he meant the new one. 4 years old and 160K kilometer's, which is, 40K klick's per year. I think he was thinking 160,000 miles per year.

    That's only approx 24,000 miles, so not horrible. Little high. Probably still used for hauling.

    Mike

    Ah yes! Now I get it - Lol! I have to agree with you, thanks. Not enough coffee yet today! :)
  • BobsYourUncle wrote:
    jdc1 wrote:
    40,000+ miles a year? Sounds like it was used for hauling.

    No, 14 years as of the 15th of this month and 403458K on it, or 250,697 miles.
    That's 28,818 K per year, or 17,906 miles per year.
    It has been my work truck since I bought it new Aug 15, 2006. Never used for hauling.

    Think he meant the new one. 4 years old and 160K kilometer's, which is, 40K klick's per year. I think he was thinking 160,000 miles per year.

    I think these year Duramax's have issues with the injectors grenading, but Im not positive. Just read a lot about the CP3 fuel injectors having issues.

    That's only approx 24,000 miles, so not horrible. Little high. Probably still used for hauling.

    Mike
  • The 2016 is four years old. It has 160000 miles on the odometer. That’s 40000 per year.
  • jdc1 wrote:
    40,000+ miles a year? Sounds like it was used for hauling.

    No, 14 years as of the 15th of this month and 403458K on it, or 250,697 miles.
    That's 28,818 K per year, or 17,906 miles per year.
    It has been my work truck since I bought it new Aug 15, 2006. Never used for hauling.
  • jdc1's avatar
    jdc1
    Explorer II
    40,000+ miles a year? Sounds like it was used for hauling.