Piercing(Tap) are used to access the closed system to allow you to recover and drain the coolant. Once that is done you solder in regular valves. Leaving a Tap valve on the copper will eventually leak as the copper will slowly smash and the rubber seal will start to leak. Some will not leak if installed correctly. But most are not installed correctly. It is highly suspect that BOTH units would loose coolant. When you DO have a leak, the amount of coolant to even cool marginally will be gone in less than a month if not completely gone. They only hold about 16ozs of Freon/410. Doug