I also used the blue foam, in fact I replaced the entire door with new materials, only kept the outer Fiberglass skin and the aluminum frame. The Blue foam was thinner than the original foam, So I added a inner layer of luan to make up the differenc...
Looks like I will be doing a similar project on my outdoor kitchen door. Realize this is a 2 year old thread but I found it very helpful!Two questions if the OP is still around. 1. What adhesives did you use? I think I see a bottle of white glue ...