cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Towable versus Motorized RV?

NekkidFish
Explorer
Explorer
Hi everybody! I have posted here in the past, but it was when we were renting RVs. Now, after renting RVs over the years, we have decided to buy.

I always thought we would buy a motorized RV. However, we now own a large truck, and could get a towable RV.

Is there anyone who used to have a motorized RV, and now have a towable RV? If so, which do you prefer and why?

Or, reverse the question ... Did you used to have a towable and now have a motorized? Same questions.

Thanks bunches! Jules
2014 Coachmen Leprechaun 319DS
Let the adventures begin!
89 REPLIES 89

NekkidFish
Explorer
Explorer
So when Kevin got home last night, I told him to go get me the info from the inside of the door of the truck. He came back and said all that was there was info on tire pressure. So, I asked him to get the owners manual. I went to the section on towing, and it has a long list of all the various trucks, and you have to know your truck's model code number. We have no clue where to find that number.

When I look at the various ones listed for the CrewMax models, the gross combination weight ratings vary between 12,500 and 16,000 pounds. The trailer weight rating varies between 6,500 and 9,800 pounds.

So, until we find out what we have, we really still don't even know if we can do a TT in the size we would want. 😕

I will post back when I find out this info. I also need to go back and read what you all wrote about the weights of the TT and how that works. This part still isn't sinking into my head.

Thanks!! Jules
2014 Coachmen Leprechaun 319DS
Let the adventures begin!

2112
Explorer II
Explorer II
You can forget the 5th wheel (FW) with the Tundra.

It has been stated here that a TT will have 10% of it's total weight as tongue weight. I trust you caught on to what they are saying.

The FW will have 20-25% pin weight. Pin weight is the weight that goes directly into the bed of the truck. Plus you have the weight of the hitch itself.

Only a select few Tundra's can handle a small FW. If you were not paying attention to payload numbers when you bought the truck I doubt you found one.
2011 Ford F-150 EcoBoost SuperCab Max Tow, 2084# Payload, 11,300# Tow,
Timbrens
2013 KZ Durango 2857

timmac
Explorer
Explorer
Campfire Time wrote:
While I have not owned a motor home, I can definitively say that we will always have a towable. For 2 main reasons. One is that care and maintenance of a towable is a fraction of the cost and time of a motorized RV. The second is usability/drivability. In many places it hard to park a motor home.

But those are my reasons. Many people own motor homes and would never consider a towable.


I would say it does not cost anymore to have a motorhome vs a truck and TT to upkeep, it comes out the same, as to parking its easier to park a motorhome than a long TT or 5th wheel.

Francesca_Knowl
Explorer
Explorer
NekkidFish wrote:
Ba hahahaha .... Oh my. That made me laugh. I guess I need to change my location on here. (Off to find where I change that.)

We moved last year, and we are now in northern Kentucky, right below Cincinati, OH.

I see you managed to change the location in your avatar....Now, THAT makes a little more sense! 🙂
" Not every mind that wanders is lost. " With apologies to J.R.R. Tolkien

DSDP_Don
Explorer
Explorer
Buy what fits your needs. When we were younger, I needed a truck to do side jobs and we towed a boat, so we had an 11' slide in Lance camper. As the kids got older and we needed more space. We were making more money and could afford a motor home and keep the truck. This gave us a truck to tow the boat locally and the motor home to tow it on longer trips.

Again, as we got older, we went with a larger motor home. We eventually sold the boat and began towing a vehicle behind the motor home. Our friends, who we routinely camp with, have a truck and fifth wheel. When we had the boat, they split fuel/docking expenses with us. Now we split fuel when we use their truck for sightseeing and leave our toad at home.

My wife likes the idea of the motor home, because she can get up and walk around, use the bathroom and get me cold drinks. Often it's nice to stop for an overnight and never have to get out of the motor home.

If I had to do it over, either would be a good choice....it just depends on works best for you. We're lucky enough to be able to park our RV at our house, but the spot requires backing up a steep angle to the parking spot, which I couldn't do with a fifth wheel or trailer.

So after that long story, the moral is......you have to see what works for you, how you intend to use it and what you can afford.
Don & Mary
2019 Newmar Dutch Star 4018 - All Electric
2019 Ford Raptor Crew Cab

NekkidFish
Explorer
Explorer
Ba hahahaha .... Oh my. That made me laugh. I guess I need to change my location on here. (Off to find where I change that.)

We moved last year, and we are now in northern Kentucky, right below Cincinati, OH.
2014 Coachmen Leprechaun 319DS
Let the adventures begin!

Francesca_Knowl
Explorer
Explorer
NekkidFish wrote:
Speed, we had around 50" here ... almost setting the record for the most snow ever. There was almost no salt to be found to salt the roads! It was so not the norm!

Sadly, the wooly worms and the Farmers Almanac are saying this winter is going to be worse. I'm hoping they're wrong. 😕

O.K., I've looked and looked again at your location....and now I simply I have to ask:

Just where the heck in "So Cal" ARE you that gets 50" of snow????
" Not every mind that wanders is lost. " With apologies to J.R.R. Tolkien

NekkidFish
Explorer
Explorer
Speed, we had around 50" here ... almost setting the record for the most snow ever. There was almost no salt to be found to salt the roads! It was so not the norm!

Sadly, the wooly worms and the Farmers Almanac are saying this winter is going to be worse. I'm hoping they're wrong. 😕
2014 Coachmen Leprechaun 319DS
Let the adventures begin!

2oldman
Explorer II
Explorer II
NekkidFish wrote:
Tom, I am using the search feature, and putting in things like 'towable versus motorized' or 'motor home versus fifth wheel'..
This would be a tough search, for this board. You probably used the little box above which defaults to 'exact phrase', which makes finding anything way difficult. The more words, the less likely it will be found. And the spelling of versus, well, that's another story.

I keep a library of links on hard-to-find subjects, and posted them earlier. I'll keep this thread too, since it's getting a lot of airplay.
"If I'm wearing long pants, I'm too far north" - 2oldman

NekkidFish
Explorer
Explorer
Great info Speed!! I will show this to hubby, so he can read all of this and understand about all of this too!

I feel like I'm going to RV school. 🙂

Yall are the best!
2014 Coachmen Leprechaun 319DS
Let the adventures begin!

Speedogomer
Explorer
Explorer
NekkidFish wrote:
Bobbo wrote:
DW has a bladder the size of a BB. It is a must for us that she can get to the bathroom while travelling down the road. A towable would not fit that requirement.


Bobbi, I have thought about that! When we came from CA to KY last Novemebrt, we ran into ice and snow storms and all of the gas stations and food marts were shut down. No problem for us in the MH we rented. We just stopped and went potty and had a snack.

Now you have me curious. If you stop somewhere, say just to have a picnic, can you not get in a towable unless it is set and balanced? (I hope that makes sense. I don't know the terminology.)


You can get in it no problem. The only issue is that many of them have slides, and they may have to be put out in order to get inside. All new RVs that have slides are powered, so it's not a huge issue. Nothing else needs to be set or leveled until you're at the campsite

I can't imagine KY having that bad of winters, I live 3 miles south of the NY state border, not far south of the snowiest cities in the USA, it wasn't very fun here. Almost 100 inches of snow last season
2016 Ram 1500 Big Horn, "Katy"
2014 Outback Terrain 260trs "Alice"
2011 French Bulldog Shelter adopted edition, "Roscoe"
1982 DW, "Rachel"
2016 DD "Harper", the newest lil camper.

Speedogomer
Explorer
Explorer
Yes to most people the Tundra is a big truck, but here in the world of RV'S,it's really the smallest truck there is, that anyone considers for towing. It's what we call a half ton. There are half tons, 3/4 tons, and 1 tons. These are the most common you hear of. Aditionally they're called 1500, 2500, and 3500 respectively. There are bigger trucks, but in the RV world you don't see quite as many, as they start getting into commercial vehicle territory. There are also a few smaller trucks like the Toyota Tacoma and Nissan frontier, but they are limited for towing, and not really talked of much around this forum.

Since you have a half ton truck, you'll be limited by 2 factors, payload and max towing weight.

Payload is the maximum weight you can out into the truck itself. Passengers and cargo both. When towing, the tongue weight is also added to this weight. The tongue weight is the weight the hitch of the trailer has pushing down on to the rear of the truck. Your payload is listed inside the driver's door on the frame, with a yellow sticker. It will say "combined weight of cargo and passengers should never exceed xxxx lbs". This is your payload.

Example: you have 1500 lbs of available payload. You have 2 people they weight 350 lbs total. 2 dogs that weigh 100 lbs total, and 50 lbs of supplies in the truck. You now have 500 lbs in the truck, and 1000 lbs left over that is available for the weight of the trailer hitch pushing down.

A TT has 10-15% of its total weight resting on the hitch. So a 10,000 lbs trailer would have 1000 to 1500 pounds of weight on the hitch. This means you'd be over your payload.

Your truck also has a maximum tow rating. This is the weight trailer it can pull. Trails have a dry weight listed, you should estimate another 1000lbs of gear to be added once you're packed and ready to camp. Add more weight if you pack heavy.

With this in mind, find out your max tow rating and your payload, this will give you an idea of what you can tow.

Truthfully, most half tons are not euipped to tow very big trailers. Your idea of big may be different though. My trailer is huge compared to the tent I grew up camping with! If you're looking for a huge home on wheel, you may have to lower expectations. If you're looking for a comfortable place to relax, you'll prob find a few trailers that fit your needs. It's unlikely you'll find a 5er that's light enough, although there are a few out there for a properly equipped half ton truck.
2016 Ram 1500 Big Horn, "Katy"
2014 Outback Terrain 260trs "Alice"
2011 French Bulldog Shelter adopted edition, "Roscoe"
1982 DW, "Rachel"
2016 DD "Harper", the newest lil camper.

NekkidFish
Explorer
Explorer
Bobbo wrote:
DW has a bladder the size of a BB. It is a must for us that she can get to the bathroom while travelling down the road. A towable would not fit that requirement.


Bobbi, I have thought about that! When we came from CA to KY last Novemebrt, we ran into ice and snow storms and all of the gas stations and food marts were shut down. No problem for us in the MH we rented. We just stopped and went potty and had a snack.

Now you have me curious. If you stop somewhere, say just to have a picnic, can you not get in a towable unless it is set and balanced? (I hope that makes sense. I don't know the terminology.)
2014 Coachmen Leprechaun 319DS
Let the adventures begin!

Bobbo
Explorer II
Explorer II
DW has a bladder the size of a BB. It is a must for us that she can get to the bathroom while travelling down the road. A towable would not fit that requirement.
Bobbo and Lin
2017 F-150 XLT 4x4 SuperCab w/Max Tow Package 3.5l EcoBoost V6
2017 Airstream Flying Cloud 23FB

NekkidFish
Explorer
Explorer
Tom, I am so sorry for the loss of your wife.

Thank you for your thoughts. We basically want a home on wheels. We aren't true camping kind of people.

I have been shopping for TT's online all day. Some of those are so huge, they really do like dragging a mobile home behind a truck. LOL

If we had the money we would be buying one of the big buses with all of the bells and whistles, but the lottery Gods haven't granted us that wish yet. Until I find out if we are going to be able to tow, or how much we can tow, I'm just sort of window shopping right now.
2014 Coachmen Leprechaun 319DS
Let the adventures begin!