Yet Another Tire Question

[Grommit]

We are replacing the tires 205/75/14 load range C tires on our trailer with a GVWR of 6500 pounds and a dry weight of 4850 pounds.

I think we are going to go with Carlisle Radial Trail either the new HD or the old RH. My question, the HD is available in a D load range for about 5 dollars more and thought this would be a smart upgrade but the some tire dealers say that I might have to under inflate them a bit to stop center tread wear and a rough ride.
Is it a good idea to use the D's or should I just replaced with C range.
Thanks for the help.

[APT]

My TT had the same sized tires. I replaced with 215/75R145 Carlisle HD this Spring.

[JIMNLIN]

Your OEM 205/75-14 C tires are rated at 1760 lb capacity x four = 7040 lb of capacity. Plenty of reserve capacity for that size trailer.

The Carlisle HD is a much better tire. I see no benefit of a D at derated pressures when a C has that much reserve capacity. Don't bit into the bigger is better just for the sake of upgrading as at some point a trailer, unlike a truck, can have too much tire capacity.

Now if the oem tires had marginal capacity and the wheels are 65 psi rated then the D at 65 psi makes cents/sense.

[rbpru]

I went with ST 205 15's that have a 65 psi load range D. They are rated load range C at 50 psi. so it gives me buffer if the pressure drops a few pounds.

My previous tires were ST 205's load range C. I change the after 15,000 miles because they were seven years old. The D rated tires were only a few dollars more.

[azdryheat]

It doesn't matter so long as Made in China is on the tire. They're all of questionable quality.

[coolbreeze01]

I've upgraded from C to E, ran 80psi, and the tires wore evenly.
I plan to buy the new HD's the next time I need tires. Let us know how you like them.

[3oaks]

Moving up a load range does increase the tire's load capacity.

But as I stated, it does not increase the trailer's load capacity (GVWR).

Tires are only one of several components that determines the GVWR.

[Second_Chance]

Moving up a load range does increase the tire's load capacity. That's what load range is all about. You will be fine and I would go with the Ds, as well. Just make sure to check the inside of the wheels to see if the wheels are rated for the new inflation pressure. That shouldn't be an issue in the lower load ranges, but it becomes one with the load range G and H tires we run on the larger fifth wheels (many wheels aren't rated for the 110 PSI on a load range G tire).

Rob

[3oaks]

My choice would be to go with the Carlisle HD Load Range D without any hesitation. 😉

When it was time for replacement tires on our TT which originally had Load Range C tires, I replaced the them Load Range D tires without any problems with ride or wear. And my trailer's GVWR was only 6,000lbs, which I was always well under even when ready for camping.

Going to LR D tires, doesn't increase the trailers capacity. It's just gives a little extra insurance against tire failures.