cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Campfires: Love them or hate them?

hedgehopper
Explorer
Explorer
For some, campfires mean bedtime stories, roasted hot dogs and marshmallows. For my wife and me, on a recent overnight at Lathrop State Park near Walsenburg CO, campfire smoke meant sneezing, itchy eyes, and runny noses. Never another campfire wouldn't break my heart.

So I'm wondering, how do the rest of you feel about campfires? Do you love them? Hate them? Or don't care one way or the other?
150 REPLIES 150

PUCampin
Explorer
Explorer
I love campfires but hardly get to build one anymore. My 5yo son is a high functioning autistic, and a runner, so he requires physical hands on nearly 100% of the time. Often by the time we get to evening, I am just too tired to make one and the girls have expressed they don't want one either. My wife likes the idea of a campfire, but if it is cool outside she heads in after a few minutes. I am hoping in a couple years the kids will be more interested and maybe my son will not be as inclined to run. This last week we went for a couple days, and our neighbors had fires, so we got to have that campfire smell and atmosphere without building one myself 🙂

It does depend some on where and the weather. I have been places, like Yosemite valley, where an inversion layer sets up and the smoke litterally sits on the valley floor like a fog. Most of the time where we camp there is enough air movement to keep it any smoke moving.
2007 Expedition EL 4x4 Tow pkg
1981 Palomino Pony, the PopUp = PUCampin! (Sold)
2006 Pioneer 180CK = (No more PUcampin!):B

Me:B DW:) and the 3 in 3 :E
DD:B 2006, DS 😛 2007, DD :C 2008

jake2250
Explorer
Explorer

Clarryhill
Explorer
Explorer
My philosophy is "to each, his own, whatever floats your boat". I don't stay in motels, but I don't build campfires either.
2014 Ford F450 PSD
2017 Lance 1172

Salty_Dog
Explorer
Explorer
It isn't camping without a campfire. While we may not have a fire every night, we usually do have one. It is the focal point we use to wind down, recap the day's experiences, and relax prior to turning in for the night. Amazing how many people will join us.
The biggest challenge I see is finding well seasoned wood to burn. Since the environmental threat of spreading insects from place to place has prohibited carrying my own seasoned wood that will burn without much smoke, it is more difficult to have a relaxing campfire.
Wife, kids, somebody else's kids, dog, kitchen sink

Cleverly disguised as an adult.

Javi1
Explorer
Explorer
If I didn't like campfires, I'd stay in motels...
2015 Keystone Cougar 333MKS
2015 Ford F-350XL 6.7 CC, DRW, RWD
(Finally enough tow vehicle 14,000 GVWR 6062 payload)

mdcamping
Explorer
Explorer


This is what I plan to be doing at Nickerson Park Campground, CT at the end of this month...campfires and eating, doesn't get any better! :C


Mike
2022 F-150 3.5 EcoBoost 4X4 Supercrew GCWR 19,500 157WB
Payload 2476 Maxtow 13,800 3.73 Equalizer 4 Pt Sway Hitch
2017 Jayco Jay Flight 24RBS
Old TV, 07 Toyota Tacoma, Double Cab, Factory Tow Pkg, retired towing at 229K. (Son now owns truck)

run100
Explorer
Explorer
Although me and the family enjoy the times we have a camp fire, it definitely doesn't detract from our trip when we don't have one. Just being there and enjoying the great outdoors does it for me! With so many other fun things to do, more often than not, we don't even have time to make a fire.
2012 F350,6.7L Diesel,4x4,CC,SB,SRW
2013 Lance 855S

tsetsaf
Explorer III
Explorer III
Love fires but hate the smoke. Just yesterday we returned from a hike and as we rounded the corner towards the campsite my heart skipped a beat. The new neighbors apparently love smoke and hate fires. There was so much smoke billowing around our rig that my first thought was that the rig was on fire.

Campfires are great when done right but en-masse, ie crowded np and sp campgrounds, they ruin the fresh air and clear views.
2006 Ram 3500
2014 Open Range
"I don't trust my own advise!"

Go_Dawgs1
Explorer
Explorer
Thats one of the main reasons to go camping. Family around the fire talking, smores, having fun and watching the kids use fire sticks.
2004 Ford F350 Lariat 4x4 Dually
2017 Grand Design Reflection 303 RLS

jake2250
Explorer
Explorer
cleary wrote:
We love them. We take our fire pit with us. Old tub out of a washing machine. They really work well

Chuck



Chuck,, we love our tub!! Just got another from a good friend today, my old one,,,, eight years old finally rusted out,, My mistake,, I didn't rinse it out last time and left the ash and coals in it..
gonna christen the new one tonight at home, roast a few wienies and smores to break it in!!

I wonder how many others use a washer tub?? Way more efficient than a fire ring!! Your picture is great!!! Got it stoked!!!

2gypsies1
Explorer II
Explorer II
d3500ram wrote:


When I am ready to retire, I will roll out the large heat sink log and let the coals start to burn down. If there is a threat of a cold front and wind potential I will dump some gray water to tame it down... otherwise the few coals and embers will be left to burn out.


This is an extremely unsafe practice. 'Dumping some water on it' or 'leaving the embers to burn out'.

Two years ago we were in Jemez Falls national forest campground in New Mexico over Memorial weekend. On Monday all but a few campers left. I was taking a walk, saw smoke in the distance and as I approached fire was traveling fast on the forest floor of pine needles from a campfire that was not fully extinguished. I went to the host who was away. I called 911 and very quickly fire trucks arrived. We and a few others were told to leave. Later on the news I heard it took 6 hours to put out that fire and the campground was closed indefinitely.

Dumping 'some' water does NOT put it out. Dumping a LOT of water and raking it out so you can put your hand in it means it's out. When you retire at night or leave your campsite for even a short time, that fire should be put completely out. Please be responsible. Our forests are precious. Thanks.
Full-Timed for 16 Years
.... Back in S&B Again
Traveled 8 yr in a 40' 2004 Newmar Dutch Star Motorhome
& 8 yr in a 33' Travel Supreme 5th Wheel

hedgehopper
Explorer
Explorer
d3500ram, thanks for the pictures. I get to enjoy your campfires with no smoke whatsoever. In what part of Colorado do you live? Hang in there, the snow will soon be gone from the high country too.

doxiemom11
Explorer II
Explorer II
Try not to burn any leaves when having a fire. Leaves contain mold spores which is what many people react to who have allergies. Clean dry wood too. If it's been laying on the forest floor, it probably has mold spores too.

restlesswind
Explorer
Explorer
I really like the campfires,the smell,the outdoor feel,etc.The problem is,they really get to my allergies.Watering eyes. sneezing stuffy nose etc.
If there were no campfires allowed,it would be OK with me.
Now,there is no way that I am going to complain about a camper that has a fire.
That is a privilege that I would not interfere with.My allergies are not his
problem.It would be nice though if the smoke was kept to a minimum. A well built fire will not produce all that much smoke.
'04 33.5 CKQG Hitchhiker Discover America
04.5 Dodge 3500 CTD SRW
Pac Brake,Max Brake
Fulltimers since '06

d3500ram
Explorer III
Explorer III
I almost always have a campfire.

The only time I do not is when a fire ban is in effect. I never have an issue of smoke getting in me, on me or in my camper... but it may be perhaps be due to understanding the lay of the land. Where I live in the mountains it is easy to predict the wind currents with respect to the time of day and the terrain. It is second nature to me because I want to know wind currents when I am hunting- I always try to hunt big game with the wind in my face. I apply the basics to where I set up camp and where I make my fire.

This photo may look like it is going into the camper (and in late after noon it might pass over the truck) But in a few hours it will completely pass away from camper and campers:



I go to a regular spot about 5 miles from home where there is a log that is constantly getting burned down from the visitors. It is still slightly "green" but it acts as a heat sink once it gets going:



I usually bring some wood from home to get it going and then scavenge from the surroundings.





Once it "gets going" it is easy to maintain at this point. The large log acts as the heat sink to keep thermal energy. I can add smaller pieces as needed to maintain the desired effect. There are enough coals established that the fire is easily maintained.

When I am ready to retire, I will roll out the large heat sink log and let the coals start to burn down. If there is a threat of a cold front and wind potential I will dump some gray water to tame it down... otherwise the few coals and embers will be left to burn out.

This is the view from said campsite early evening which wind drifts will later take any smoke away from the quality sitting and drinking area:



Folks, bear with me and I thank you for your patience. It is snowing now tonight and I will need to shovel again tomorrow. The following are some of the views from this one of many favorite camping spots of which I frequent.

With the spoils of living in a beautiful area come the pitfalls of snow even in mid April. Enjoy the photos and forgive me for bragging as I pour another Jack and long for the High Country summer days once again... and in the spirit of this thread topic...

Show me some of YOUR best campfires!!



This may look as if smoke is rolling towards the camper, but upon starting there is some random smoke as the heat develops. But when the heat really stats to happen it will pick up the wind currents of the terrain. I try to look for the best currents of the later hours to enjoy a hassle free fire later in the evening:



Here is an indicator of the fire in relation to the camper locate (for best leveling) and in anticipation of the night currents:



Folks... thanks for bearing with this disertion on fire theory. It has (is) been a long winter and I long for the 2 months of summer that I have locally. I live for these days where my camping is oh so hassle free and local. It is further for me to drive get a 6 pack of beer than it is to get to places like these. Thanks for thw slack, but it it is still winter for me:





Oh...BTW, I never cook over softwood fires no matter how hot the coals are. Hardwood is only what I use for cooking.




Thanks for reading... good food, good drink and RV.net is what get me through long winters. More photos of where I live will follow soon!

Let's see some of your best fires!
Sold the TC, previous owner of 2 NorthStar pop-ups & 2 Northstar Arrows...still have the truck:

2005 Dodge 3500 SRW, Qcab long bed, NV-6500, diesel, 4WD, Helwig, 9000XL,
Nitto 285/70/17 Terra Grapplers, Honda eu3000Is, custom overload spring perch spacers.