Dish Or Direct

[Redterpos3]

We are moving from PA to Upstate NY (actually not too far, just 1/2 hr over the border. But we have the opportunity this time to have Dish TV or Direct TV or Cable at home. I'm thinking of using the Cable for our internet but may want to go with either Dish or Direct for our Television, as I've never had either of these.

Which is best to combine with the RV?
What receiver(s) do I need to do this in the RV?
Which one do people like (very subjective I know, I'd like opinions)?
Can I use 2 wireless receivers in the RV?

I have about a month to do my research!

[Big_Katuna]

As happy as I am with DISH and the Hopper/Joey, they dont work with any of the auto carry out antennas.

I use a tripod and a house type dish so it works with the Hopper but got tired of taking it all out every time we went camping so I bought a 211 DVR to take and leave the Hopper home to record shows.

It will work with the Winegard Pathway X 2. $400 not $1800.

A roof top doesn't work for us. I have a dome now that hasn't been used in years.

We camp where there are trees if we can.

[stevewise]

Dish have the month to month plan Direct does not also if you have dish at home they will just add everything you have at home to your RV, but make sure your SAT is for Dish.

[TechWriter]

2chiefsRus wrote:
Be sure when you are purchasing SAT equipment for the RV, that you take into consideration that SD (standard definition) service for Directv will likely be stopped sometime around the end of 2019. That is why we went ahead and upgraded our in-motion SD dome to HD (High Definition) service from Directv with the roof mounted Winegard Trav'ler. It was expensive . . .

Before you shell out the big bucks for a Travler, consider switching to DISH. DISH's whole house DVR (Hopper 3) is head and shoulders above DirecTV offerings + there's Prime Time Any Time.

[2chiefsRus]

Be sure when you are purchasing SAT equipment for the RV, that you take into consideration that SD (standard definition) service for Directv will likely be stopped sometime around the end of 2019. That is why we went ahead and upgraded our in-motion SD dome to HD (High Definition) service from Directv with the roof mounted Winegard Trav'ler. It was expensive but works well for us. We still have an SD portable sat dish that we can use when we are parked under trees blocking the roof-mounted Trav'ler.

[Not_a_Clue]

-----

[Big_Katuna]

I have had both and recently switched to DISH as they have a two year 190 channels for $49/mo, no charge for HD or DVR service, free premiums for three months, prepaid Netflix for one year.

HD in an RV is hard with Directv. No automatic carry out like for DISH.

I like DISH better than I did DTV.

[rk911]

all dish receivers are now (now meaning as of when we acquired DISH last fall) eligible for the pay-as-you-go plans. we have the VIP722k dvr/receiver and the Winegard Trav'ler automatic dish antenna on the roof.

[aslakson]

We have DirecTV because they have some channels we like a lot that Dish doesn't. And we have just one receiver - a Genie - that drives both TV sets thru an HDMI splitter.

al

[Bill_Satellite]

Redterpos3 wrote:
We are moving from PA to Upstate NY (actually not too far, just 1/2 hr over the border. But we have the opportunity this time to have Dish TV or Direct TV or Cable at home. I'm thinking of using the Cable for our internet but may want to go with either Dish or Direct for our Television, as I've never had either of these.

Which is best to combine with the RV?
What receiver(s) do I need to do this in the RV?
Which one do people like (very subjective I know, I'd like opinions)?
Can I use 2 wireless receivers in the RV?

I have about a month to do my research!

Both services work well with an RV. What antenna type you use in the RV will effect both services. If you want to use a dome style antenna (roof mounted or portable automatic) you cannot get HD with DirecTV and you are limited to only 1 signal tuner receiver with Dish. Yes, a DVR or second receiver can be used but there will always be conflicts.
Again, the type receiver you use in the RV will depend upon the antenna type you select for the RV. The Hopper (Dish) and Genie (DirecTV) will not operate with a dome but work great with a Trav'ler or a ground mounted tripod with full sized home antenna.
You cannot use 2 wireless receivers in the RV. These are only clients and must have a Hopper or Genie as the source for the satellite signal which is hard wired. A wireless client receiver can then be used at a 2nd location.

[Dutch_12078]

We prefer Dish in part for the ease of changing our service location as we move from place to place. We like to watch the local channels for the area we're in.

We have a two Hopper system with a Joey and use a tripod mounted dish that can be configured for either Dish satellite arc. It typically takes me less than 15 minutes to set up and aim it.

[donn0128]

Take your pick. Do you like sports? Direct offers better sports packages. Either can be taken and used in your RV with the proper antenna. With the direct protection pqckage I have one number support and replacement equipment if needed no hassles

[dahkota]

We have dish, a trav'ler, a hopper and a joey for our RV.
What you get will completely depend on how cheap you want to go and how much effort you want to put into getting satellite service.

If you want to go cheap, get a manual dish and tripod for the service you want and take the receiver/s from the house. This will be the most work every time you travel.

If you want to go easy, get an automatic dish such as the Pathway X2, and a 211 receiver. This will be more expensive at the beginning but will save you time when you travel. (If you require HD you will want Dish rather than Direct.)

[Ranger_Smith]

We have Dish in the RV. I like it because they have a "pay as you go" plan. If you want to use it just pay the bill. If you don't need it for 2 or 3 months don't pay the invoice then when you are ready to travel just pay for the service. No contract like with direcTV. It is also easier and less expensive to get HD with Dish. The receivers for the RV are the VIP 211. You can even add a hard drive for a recorder.