I had the opposite problem recently where mine in the on/auto mode would jump straight to propane and would not work on electric when hooked to shore power. After testing the heater rod and other recommended diagnostics, I was sure it had to be the main lower circuit board and replaced it only to find the problem still existed.
After much frustration, I decided to replace the eyebrow circuit board which houses the on/off/auto and propane switch. That resolved my issue and now works in both modes.
Since your propane works in auto only after unplugging the shorepower I would think that would mean all of the propane ignition systems are working once receiving the proper command from the main circuit board. I'm wondering if there's a possibility that the eyebrow circuit board is not providing the right signal to operate on propane only when switched to override auto. Just a thought !!!
Walter and Janie Rogers
2012 Sundance 277RL
TV 2006 Silverado 2500 6.0