Question for mechanics about replacement starters?

[colliehauler]

I need to replace the starter in my F-250 V-10. On ebay the price range for a new starters varies considerably. From $35. to $200. I figured sticking to a name brand would be best. Some of the cheap new starters come with a 5 year warranty. What would you recomend?

[Old-Biscuit]

shum02 wrote:

time2roll wrote:

midnightsadie wrote:
I can,t beleave you went to rock auto,they have the cheapest made stuff on earth. a rebuilt would have been a better starter. but I( hope it works out good for you.

I hope he got the new AC Delco model for $120.

I order from them all the time. Rock Auto is just a middle man to dozens and dozens of suppliers including Ford dealerships.

I have ordered from Rock Auto for years
You CAN buy cheap or you can buy higher quality just less expensive

One just needs to scroll thru the items available and pick based on quality vs JUST pricing.

They 'sell' same stuff available elsewhere just better price point.

[Grit_dog]

Cummins12V98 wrote:

Grit dog wrote:
Depends if you're fixing it to sell or keep for a long time.
IMO, quality parts stores like Napa and Carquest used to have good reman parts. Now they're all the same junk as the bargain parts stores. Anything with the Dorman brand is c rap.

I would take a quality REMAN starter from NAPA any day over a new one from them because the new will be a giant POS made in China.

They are NOT the NAPA they used to be!!!

Then they've changed in the last couple years? That's good to know.

[colliehauler]

Well got a surprise the starter had been replaced before with a Ultima remanufactured starter. Took less the 5 minutes to pull it, took longer to round up safety glasses and tools and jack up the truck. I can't believe how small it is compared to the Diesel starter.

[colliehauler]

shum02 wrote:

time2roll wrote:

midnightsadie wrote:
I can,t beleave you went to rock auto,they have the cheapest made stuff on earth. a rebuilt would have been a better starter. but I( hope it works out good for you.

I hope he got the new AC Delco model for $120.

I order from them all the time. Rock Auto is just a middle man to dozens and dozens of suppliers including Ford dealerships.

I ordered a TYC from Rock Auto, should be here Thursday. Will go to the storage lot and get the 99 7.3 Diesel to drive until I replace the starter.

[shum02]

time2roll wrote:

midnightsadie wrote:
I can,t beleave you went to rock auto,they have the cheapest made stuff on earth. a rebuilt would have been a better starter. but I( hope it works out good for you.

I hope he got the new AC Delco model for $120.

I order from them all the time. Rock Auto is just a middle man to dozens and dozens of suppliers including Ford dealerships.

[Groover]

I had some bad experiences with rebuilt starters 20 or more years ago but not since then. I have no reservations about using rebuilt starters now.

[NRALIFR]

Nobody mentioned this, so I will.

I have had limited experience (5-6 times) with DB Electrical (dbelectrical.com) for car, truck, and tractor starters and alternators, but 100% satisfaction.

New parts very competitively priced. No core charge IIRC.

:):)

[colliehauler]

1320Fastback wrote:
I'd rebuild it myself before getting anything but OEM. Part are available and they really very easy to disassemble.

As I said above I will replace the starter and rebuild the old starter when I have some time. Rainy day project. Ironically just changed the starter in my old 99 7.3 Diesel earlier this year.

[1320Fastback]

I'd rebuild it myself before getting anything but OEM. Part are available and they really very easy to disassemble.

[colliehauler]

theoldwizard1 wrote:

Cummins12V98 wrote:
Have it professionally rebuilt.

Is there ANYWHERE in the US that does this ?

Permanent magnet starters are really very simple. The only wear items are the bearing, the brushes and the commutator. While the windings need to be tested for sort and opens (not likely if the commutator does not have excessive wear) they do not commonly fail.

Clean the commutator bars with 200+ grit every cloth. Replace the brushes. Replace the solenoid (if you can find a replacement).

I will probably rebuild the old starter since I have more then one truck that uses the same starter. I don't know if the starter is actually bad it might be the solenoid. Have to pull the starter to get to it so will just change it out.

[time2roll]

midnightsadie wrote:
I can,t beleave you went to rock auto,they have the cheapest made stuff on earth. a rebuilt would have been a better starter. but I( hope it works out good for you.

I hope he got the new AC Delco model for $120.

[theoldwizard1]

Cummins12V98 wrote:
Have it professionally rebuilt.

Is there ANYWHERE in the US that does this ?

Permanent magnet starters are really very simple. The only wear items are the bearing, the brushes and the commutator. While the windings need to be tested for sort and opens (not likely if the commutator does not have excessive wear) they do not commonly fail.

Clean the commutator bars with 200+ grit every cloth. Replace the brushes. Replace the solenoid (if you can find a replacement).

[midnightsadie]

I can,t beleave you went to rock auto,they have the cheapest made stuff on earth. a rebuilt would have been a better starter. but I( hope it works out good for you.

[colliehauler]

bid_time wrote:
That truck is probably worth $2,000 max. It sure ain't worth putting a $200 starter on it. Put $75 - $100 starter on it. If it last 5 years you got your moneys worth out of it. Good luck with that top bolt.

In your neck of the woods it would be rusted out. My truck has zero rust, even above the wheel wells. I will drive the truck until it has a major failure so value is irrelevant to me.