cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Advice on purchase: Manadalay 40E and Monaco Dynasty???

falconman
Explorer
Explorer
Looking at a 2007 Mandalay 40E, dealer asking 110K. Unit has 26K miles. This is our first MH, currently FT in TT. Any issues I should be concerned with? It has some cosmetic issues but seems pretty decent. Never ridden in a Class A before and wife was concerned about some loud squeaks and rattles on the test drive, is this normal?

Also looking at 2005 era Monaco Dynasty's Platinum III and IV.. Upper end of what we are looking to spend, but we really like the fit and finish, mechanical features, floorplan, etc. And we know quality costs. Any Monaco owners with comments/advice on possible issues with these years (04-06), or the Dynasty model, will be greatly appreciated. We rode in one today, and it was much smoother and didn't shake, rattle, and roll like the Mandalay. Maybe it was just one bad Mandalay, don't know.

The Monaco we saw today has some definite issues that take this particular unit out of the running, (poor care, actual hole in the floor under the passenger seat, certain things inoperable, repo history, etc.), but we will continue looking.

Any advice on these two brands and models will be appreciated. Thanks.
14 REPLIES 14

JimM68
Explorer
Explorer
dynasty.
Jim M.
2008 Monaco Knight 40skq, moho #2
The "68"
My very own new forumfirstgens.com

My new blog

falconman
Explorer
Explorer
Your observations and info are invaluable! The more, the better. We appreciate it all!

Mike, long replies are great when they contain great information. Thank you!

JetA, thank you very much for the wrist pin engine issue info. We will check the engine numbers on any coach we see! That is so critical!

zmotorsports
Explorer
Explorer
Okay, I will jump on the Dynasty band wagon here as well. We have been quite pleased with our 03 Dynasty. I agree with the "best bang for the buck". We noticed this as we were looking and were actually able to get a 2003 for the similar price of a 1999-2000 Exec/Sig loaded very similar except with the ISL rather than either the M11 or the ISM (depending on years). The Exec and Sig. have the higher HP/torque engines with the Allison 4000 series transmission but also have a 4.30:1 gear ratio whereas the Dynasty has the 4.78:1 gear ratio. The mechanical advantage of the lower gear ratio on the smaller engine helps dramatically as the Dynasty is a heavy coach. I would compare the Dynasty to the other two upper models as having the same meat and potatoes and less of the frills or "fluff" as the Exec. and Sig. models. Nothing wrong with that, I like fluff but in our price range we wanted a solid coach and didn't need as much flash, nor afford the flash. Ours was loaded up with all of the options we wanted such as air leveling, Aqua-Hot, walnut interior, triple roof air units and a 10k watt Onan QD all in a 40' coach(didn't want to go to 42'). Almost unheard of in a 40' coach but the original/previous owners who ordered the coach must have been tapped into my mind when they ordered "our" coach for us.:)

That said, I would suggest looking closely at a couple of things when looking at coaches. The Aqua-Hot units built in 2002 and earlier had the domestic water line wrapped around the exterior of the boiler tank held on by a heat transferring paste. This was a good design but in these units I feel they did a poor job of brazing/silver soldering the copper neck onto the steel boiler tank. I think they used too little of solder and didn't flow it out well enough.

When we purchased ours we had a glycol leak that took me a bit to locate. Personally, I think the previous owners knew this and this is why they opted to trade it in on a new coach. I finally narrowed it down to the Aqua Hot unit itself as the leaking point but could not pinpoint it exactly due to access being somewhat limited. I removed the Aqua-Hot unit and set it up on the workbench so I could do some bench testing. Almost immediately I noticed that the tank would not hold a vacuum but it would hold pressure. I had two testers in which I was using to locate the leak. It was right where the neck and boiler tank met. Easy fix, unsoldered the connection, cleaned and re-soldered it. I also added a bit more solder around the seam as some "added insurance" so it wouldn't happen again.

About a year later my aunt/uncle's 1998 Beaver Marquis developed the same exact symptom and I walked right the issue. Later my cousin's 1998 Signature developed the same exact leak.

In late 2002/early 2003 according to Aqua-Hot (previously known as Vehicle Systems Inc.) they redesigned their domestic line/boiler tank. Now the domestic water line runs internally in the boiler tank. I have heard it is a better design, however, I am not convinced it is better, just different design is all I am going to say. Where the copper fittings go into the steel tank there is a possiblility of leaking at this point of intrusion.

Now on to the chassis, you will love the Roadmaster S-Series chassis. It is a semi-monocoque design and is probably one of the best in the industry. Actually the Country Coach Magna and Affinity on the Dynomax chassis are very similar only with IFS. There is a long debate on IFS vs. outboard mounted airbags but that would be almost a book and there are already multiple threads on the subject if you would like to search. Personally, I like the outboard mounted airbags and the stability that it provides. The ride of the dual outboard mounted airbags is a little more firm compared to the IFS which feels a bit more "cooshy" if that makes sense. The Newells and Prevost coaches use a similar chassis design only more of a full mononocoque design.

One thing that I would suggest looking at on the Roadmaster chassis is where the tag axle vertical supports are welded to the main frame rails. Under normal driving conditions this should never be an issue, however, if for some reason the coach is towed improperly, such as with a front wheel lift, this puts extreme pressures on the tag axle. Pressures and force which the axle was not designed to handle. I have seen these vertical supports break loose from the main frame rails on a couple of coaches and the owners didn't even know it. And yes they had recently been towed. This is why Monaco, as well as other manufacturers, ONLY recommend towing their tag axle coaches via a lowboy trailer, not a front wheel lift.

In approx. 2008 model year Roadmaster S-Series chassis, they added some rather large gussets on these vertical tag axle supports. I was lucky to have a great dealer who let me use one of the new coaches he had on his lot to make some patterns. I fabricated and welded these gussets onto my older 2003 Dynasty (built on a 2002 chassis).

Sorry for the lengthy description but I don't think you can go wrong with the mid-2000 era Dynasty coaches as far as quality and amenities for your money. Ours just turned over 95k miles and is still rock solid going down the highway.

Mike.
2003 Monaco Dynasty/ 26' Haulmark Edge trailer
2011 Jeep Unlimited Rubicon

loydt
Explorer
Explorer
I second the Monaco. When I have the option, I choose it over the newer Itasca we have.
2021 Jayco Seismic 4212 (on order)
2021 Jayco White Hawk 32BH
2018 Ram 3500 DRW 4x4 CC Cummins/Aisin Laramie Longhorn

JetAonly
Explorer
Explorer
I think the '04-'06 Dynasty's are the best bang for your buck, of course I'm a bit biased. There was a wrist pin issue on some ISL motors built in those years. ESN's from 46543077 to 46603939, this is independent of MH manufacturer. I would stay away from those engines.

Look for Aqua Hot and Air leveling, there were a few ordered without them.

Good Luck!
2000 Monaco Dynasty
ISC350

Mr_Mark1
Explorer
Explorer
Falconman, I would definitely pass on that Dynasty that you mentioned unless you can get it for a steal.

An '05 Dynasty is similar to our '08.

I've replaced my 'red hat' valve twice just getting the new one a couple of months ago. This valve is what allows you to put water in your fresh-water tank through the shore water hose. Both times, the valve stuck in the fresh water fill position. This time, I bought the valve myself and had it installed so it came with directions. They say to use it monthly to keep it from sticking (now I know).

Our coolant tank on the engine has been replaced twice and it looks like I'm going to have to get another one. The current one is one year old and passed its warranty. The recent repair on it didn't work, it is leaking at the top fittings. The JB weld that the Cummins shop put on it didn't take so now that I'm 2,000 miles away from the shop, I may as well get a new box and be done with it.

I try to keep on top of maintenance and repairs so there is never a long list. Whoever gets our coach will get a super well maintained unit (new tires and AGM batteries). You might find it at a consignment shop in about 8-10 months as we are thinking of trading up to our last coach.


One thing I can say about the Monaco line of coaches, is that they had beautiful woodwork and fit and finish. Especially in their upper end coaches.

MM.
Mr.Mark
2021.5 Pleasure Way Plateau FL Class-B on the Sprinter Chassis
2018 Mini Cooper Hardtop Coupe, 2 dr., 6-speed manual
(SOLD) 2015 Prevost Liberty Coach, 45 ft, 500 hp Volvo
(SOLD) 2008 Monaco Dynasty, 42 ft, 425 hp Cummins

JimM68
Explorer
Explorer
Agree on the monaco. The 8 bag chassis models, kinght, diplomat, and HR ambasador and endeaver, are head and shoulders above the mandolay.
A Dynasty, that's not even on the same street.
Jim M.
2008 Monaco Knight 40skq, moho #2
The "68"
My very own new forumfirstgens.com

My new blog

JimM68
Explorer
Explorer
Passin Thru wrote:
One thing to look for is that a lot of RV have wasted floor space down the center. All the furniture is against the walls so 4 ft xtra on each side is just hauling around another couple tons of air. There are quiet ones out there but even your silverware will rattle a little. Turn up the music!



As someone who carries 150 pounds of 2 dawgs, as well as 250 pounds of 2 teenagers, there is no wasted space down the cetner. ("wasted space" shared by all 3 and 4 slide motorhomes)

I would not trade the interior space of my 4 slide fortyfooter for anything
Jim M.
2008 Monaco Knight 40skq, moho #2
The "68"
My very own new forumfirstgens.com

My new blog

MarcW
Explorer
Explorer
In my opinion you can not do better for the money than a well equipped mid-2000 Dynasty. The tag axel S Chassis is a very solid and stable platform. A real pleasure to drive and your observation is right... they have a very nice fit and finish with high end materials. The wood is exceptional. Be sure to look for high end options like the residential fridge and Aquahot when comparing. Dynasty's are commonly equipped with those and buying used you'll be getting them for a bargain. They are nice to have. Take your time... I own a '07 Dynasty and so I'm always looking to see what they're going for and I've seen some real eye opener deals over the years.
2007 Monaco Dynasty Emperor IV
2013 Jeep Wrangler Rubicon

Passin_Thru
Explorer
Explorer
One thing to look for is that a lot of RV have wasted floor space down the center. All the furniture is against the walls so 4 ft xtra on each side is just hauling around another couple tons of air. There are quiet ones out there but even your silverware will rattle a little. Turn up the music!

Executive45
Explorer III
Explorer III
The Dynasty was the third in line of luxury coaches in those years. All Monaco luxury coaches, Signature, Executive and Dynasty, were the only coaches that had steel cage construction. The Camelot has taken over the Dynasty's spot and the Dynasty has taken over the Executive's, which has been discontinued.

Pick out a floor plan you like. PPL is a great place to do that. DeMartini.com is another. Once you decide on a model, then shop for that particular one. The Platinum IV is an awesome coach. Don't judge everything by one coach. We went to buy a Platinum IV and like the one you saw, it had too many issues. DW saw our Exec on the lot and the rest, as they say, was history.....Dennis
We can do more than we think we can, but most do less than we think we do
Dennis and Debi Fourteen Years Full Timing
Monaco Executive M-45PBQ Quad Slide
525HP Cummins ISM 6 Spd Allison
2014 Chevrolet Equinox LTZ W/ ReadyBrute
CLICK HERE TO VIEW OUR TRAVEL BLOG

wny_pat1
Explorer
Explorer
I go with the Monaco Dynasty long before the Mandalay. IMHO keep looking.
“All journeys have secret destinations of which the traveler is unaware.”

Fishinghat
Explorer II
Explorer II
DoubleVeteran wrote:
I suggest you go to some dealers nearby and test drive some of their used coaches that you are interested in so you get a feel for what is normal and what is not. I test drove about 8 different coaches before I decided on my 2002 Phaeton; it was worth my time and effort to shop around and test drive.


X2

You are about to spend some serious money. Do your due diligence. Check out PPL Motorhomes in Texas for prices on sold units to give you some idea what your money should buy. To answer your question, I'd vote for the Dynasty. They are really nice coaches.
Holiday Rambler Navigator DP, Hummer, and Honda VT1100C Shadow

DoubleVeteran
Explorer
Explorer
I suggest you go to some dealers nearby and test drive some of their used coaches that you are interested in so you get a feel for what is normal and what is not. I test drove about 8 different coaches before I decided on my 2002 Phaeton; it was worth my time and effort to shop around and test drive.