cancel
Showing results forย 
Search instead forย 
Did you mean:ย 

Is there a good app for long distance secondary roads?

Naio
Explorer II
Explorer II
I spend ridiculous amounts of time trying to get google maps to cough up the smaller roads -- zooming in and out, trying terrain mode -- then I pull out the ol' paper map and they are right there!

But the phone is more convenient, where I have a signal. Is there an app for this?

I'm talking about anything from minor state highways down to BLM 2-tracks. I'm specifically excluding topo maps because I need a scale where I can see 100-200 mile routes at a glance... like, say, a AAA map.
3/4 timing in a DIY van conversion. Backroads, mountains, boondocking, sometimes big cities for a change of pace.
38 REPLIES 38

CavemanCharlie
Explorer III
Explorer III
I do feel for the OP though. I've lived within 50 miles of the same place for 40 years. If I rely on Google Maps they seem to take me down the same roads as everyone else. But, because I have lived here for so long I know shorter, less traveled by, and good highways that the computerized thing will not show me.

bacil
Explorer
Explorer
pnichols wrote:
bacil wrote:
actually it does good in long and short distances, i have first time tested in mojave desert and with downloaded maps i managed to traverse whole NP on secondary roads with turn by turn (with some missed turns i have to add).

It has some camping grounds and hiking trails as well so for me its the one that i use in great outdoors.


Does that App require Internet access to either use, or update?

Many areas do not have Internet access.


You can download required maps prior going offline (thats what i did for Mojave as there is no reception) it stores the map on the device. See the pic i selected Mojave, with max zoom so after its downloaded i can zoom in as much as possible when online (obviously to safe on data you can choose max zoom level)


pnichols
Explorer II
Explorer II
bacil wrote:
actually it does good in long and short distances, i have first time tested in mojave desert and with downloaded maps i managed to traverse whole NP on secondary roads with turn by turn (with some missed turns i have to add).

It has some camping grounds and hiking trails as well so for me its the one that i use in great outdoors.


Does that App require Internet access to either use, or update?

Many areas do not have Internet access.
2005 E450 Itasca 24V Class C

bacil
Explorer
Explorer
Naio wrote:
Bacil, that looks like a great app! IIUC, it is more for close up stuff?


actually it does good in long and short distances, i have first time tested in mojave desert and with downloaded maps i managed to traverse whole NP on secondary roads with turn by turn (with some missed turns i have to add).

It has some camping grounds and hiking trails as well so for me its the one that i use in great outdoors.

pnichols
Explorer II
Explorer II
Naio,

After several years of RV'ing - sometimes to obscure places (we're rockhounds) - we've found that there is no substitute for map detail and that it's best to not have to rely on Internet access. What this means is:

1. Use a satellite based navigator unit that you keep updated and that you also keep loaded with thousands of custom Points of Interest way beyond the stock ones that the navigator manufacturer includes with their updates.

2. Use superb ultra-detailed maps like those from BENCHMARK (an entire large format atlas per state): https://www.benchmarkmaps.com/atlases
2005 E450 Itasca 24V Class C

afidel
Explorer II
Explorer II
You might try Sygic maps, pretty good detail even at a few hundred miles zoom and they have full offline functionality which is obviously a plus if you're boondocking ๐Ÿ˜ƒ

Here's an example at ~500 miles north to south:
link, because the forum doesn't like the actual picture.
2019 Dutchman Kodiak 293RLSL
2015 GMC 1500 Sierra 4x4 5.3 3.42 full bed
Equalizer 10k WDH

2gypsies1
Explorer II
Explorer II
Naio wrote:
My California one does not. That's the only one I tried. I didn't realise they were not standardized from state to state!


They are. We have one for every western state and BLM and all public areas are marked. They have different color shading from each other. Are you sure you're using Benchmark and not DeLorme?
Full-Timed for 16 Years
.... Back in S&B Again
Traveled 8 yr in a 40' 2004 Newmar Dutch Star Motorhome
& 8 yr in a 33' Travel Supreme 5th Wheel

Gdetrailer
Explorer III
Explorer III
Naio writes โ€œYou are confused about what I am looking for.

I just spent 30 minutes trying to find a way to do a screenshot so I could show you, but you will have to imagine.

I am looking at a Maps image out west. The scale indicates my current view is about. 200 miles x 400 miles. There are two yellow lines on the screen one near the top and one near the bottom. Those are freeways. The rest of the screen is blank, white.

I know there are roads in that blank white area the size of my palm. I would like SOME of them to show up.

Does this help?โ€


Iโ€™m not confused.

I am trying to explain that your phone, tablet, laptop or desktop PC is not able to show this detail when zoomed out that far for many reasons.

Number one reason, as others have mentioned is CLUTTER, removing small roads when zoomed out cleans up a otherwise extremely messy looking cluttered screen with very tiny lines everywhere.

Picture a spiderweb of tiny roads pasted on your screen..

Makes it much easier to read on a space limited electronic screen as opposed to a huge three foot wide piece of paper.

Electronic maps assume when zoomed out you are looking for MAJOR routes or roads, not tiny little secondary roads. Most folk are more interested in getting from point A to Point B quickly and efficiently..

Secondary roads typically are slower speeds, often are a less direct route, many times requires backtracking and more turns onto different roads and often take you through one stop light towns with very slow speed limits.. Making your trip considerably longer in time and mileage.

Other reasons are very technical but in a nutshell, it IS limitations with your screen size, resolution, phone processor, memory and data useage.

The blank white areas are blank because it would require vast amounts of data that you most likely are not interested or willing to pay for and would take hrs to days to download. So, in order for the digital map apps to work with reasonable data amounts, speed and fit to your tiny screen SOME DATA MUST BE DISCARDED.

Anytime you scale down, some data MUST BE DISCARDED, that is how digital things work.

You HAVE run into one of the drawbacks of the world of digitization.

Although, CoPilot DOES give you the option to download maps to your device, it can take several hrs per state but even with the downloaded maps it removes the fine detail from your screen when zoomed out.

Here are some examples to show you, I randomly chose NC, because I know it is about 400 miles across east to west.

First view is 1โ€ to 30 miles scale.


If you notice, the 1โ€ to 30 miles shows the entire east to west of NC and mainly Interstate roads.

Next view is 1โ€ to 1 mile scale.


Zooming to 1โ€ to 1 mile scale you now start to see some secondary roads.

Next view is 1โ€ to 2000ft scale.


Zooming in further you start seeing many more small roads.

Next view is 1โ€ to 500ft scale.


Zooming in to 1โ€ to 500ft you now start seeing city blocks.

These views were taken from Mapquest and my desktop PC with a monitor setting of 1920x1080, sadly to show them on the forum they will be degraded to 600 wide 400 high.

Perhaps you could make your own digital map rendition the way you want?

Zoom in on a map, then copy and paste that to a picture document, move the map then copy and paste that to your pic doc.. Repeat the process a few thousand times then you will have the map you are asking for but you still wonโ€™t be able to view all the fine little detail without zooming in closer.

Or, do like I have, scan or take a photo of your paper maps, but you still will need to zoom in considerably in order to be able to view the finer detail.

I wish you good luck on your endeavor to find an app to do what you want, they simply do not exist for many reasons but you are not willing to listen to reason.

Paper maps still have relevance in this modern world..

Somethings like fine detail of a paper map that is over three feet wide just cannot be replicated on a digital 7โ€ or 8โ€ screen.

Naio
Explorer II
Explorer II
My California one does not. That's the only one I tried. I didn't realise they were not standardized from state to state!
3/4 timing in a DIY van conversion. Backroads, mountains, boondocking, sometimes big cities for a change of pace.

2gypsies1
Explorer II
Explorer II
Naio wrote:
Benchmark broke my heart by not showing BLM land!


Why sure it does. I'm looking at the Arizona Benchmark right now and it shows BLM.
Full-Timed for 16 Years
.... Back in S&B Again
Traveled 8 yr in a 40' 2004 Newmar Dutch Star Motorhome
& 8 yr in a 33' Travel Supreme 5th Wheel

GordonThree
Explorer
Explorer
Secondary roads not showing for me on that app when zoomed out, only major roadways, same as Google.
2013 KZ Sportsmen Classic 200, 20 ft TT
2020 RAM 1500, 5.7 4x4, 8 speed

fyrflie
Explorer III
Explorer III
I have been using Maps.me

Great zoomed out view of primary and secondary roads throughout the US and Australia. Have not used in other countries yet.

As you zoom into a specific area it will prompt you to download a more detailed map of that area. Minor downside, maybe. May require some preplanning or WiFi or Data.
But the detailed maps donโ€™t take up much space. And you can delete unused maps easily.

Have not tried to use offroad.

Simple to use turn by turn navigation feature.

GordonThree
Explorer
Explorer
From Google; they removed streets and other secondary roads from the map in 2016 to make the map easier to read.

They added an option in 2017 to avoid highways and major roads. It's in the route planning menu. It will show your route crossing blank map unless you zoom in.
2013 KZ Sportsmen Classic 200, 20 ft TT
2020 RAM 1500, 5.7 4x4, 8 speed

GordonThree
Explorer
Explorer
Chasing unicorns here, like gde was trying to convey, it's not possible.

If topographical maps don't work for you and Google maps don't work for you, then paper maps are probably the best solution.
2013 KZ Sportsmen Classic 200, 20 ft TT
2020 RAM 1500, 5.7 4x4, 8 speed