Would you like

[Vet_Man]

I spend quite a bit of time on this site answer my share of questions for over 10 years. wouldn't it be nice if when we answer some ones questions and take our time to do it, if they came back to tell us how they made out and if we helped them. Instead od never hearing from them again until they have another problem?

[Carb_Cleaner]

2012Coleman wrote:
... Givers don't usually give with the expectation of getting something back.

This. Also, takers often take with no expectation of giving something back.
I don't expect fireworks and a steak dinner for answering someone's question (if, by some miracle I actually do correctly answer a question), but it is nice to get a thank you. More importantly, their final results of using/not using suggestions may be useful to others that have a similiar situation in the future. What a resource that would be. Although, if everybody found an answer by doing a forum search, the forum wouldn't be a forum. It'd be a database. Where's the fun in that?
I read a quote a few weeks ago that's stuck in my head. I think it was on a bicycle forum. It doesn't really apply so much here, but I thought it was both hilarious and sad. Paraphrasing:
"I have a magic box that contains the wealth of the whole World's knowledge, but I use it to look at pictures of cats and to argue with strangers."

[campigloo]

PET PEEVE. Great idea!

[2012Coleman]

A lot of times people ask a question and get all kinds of unsolicited advice. A few regulars on here like to just keep adding to these off topic answers, by piling on their off topic opinions/assumptions to the top of the heap. I don't blame OPs for not coming back.

I belong to some techinical forums where you gain reputation for having the correct answer - your answer being marked as The Answer by the OP. There is no such contest on here.

Somebody also stated that there are givers and takers. Givers don't usually give with the expectation of getting something back.

[FunnyCamper]

:S here we go again 🙂

Mods---we need a PET PEEVE subcategory please :R

[Tom_Diane]

Vet Man wrote:
I spend quite a bit of time on this site answer my share of questions for over 10 years. wouldn't it be nice if when we answer some ones questions and take our time to do it, if they came back to tell us how they made out and if we helped them. Instead od never hearing from them again until they have another problem?

I find it interesting that the op expects a response from a poster that has a question that there is no response and finds it offensive or somehow not proper etiquette! There are 3 pages of replies to VET Man's post and as of 11:05 PM and he has not acknowledged if his question was answered or not! Or if his issue is solved! The op posted at 9:41 AM. I like to hear if my answer to a post helped someone resolve an issue. Or if I contributed in some way. I don't lose sleep if I don't get an acknowledgement one way or the other! There is another side to this etiquette. It involves a response that belittles the poster because for whatever reason, it has been hashed over before or the reply is you cant do it or don't be on the road when I'm on it because your not safe etc. A little common courtesy goes both ways. Do we really need our egos stroked because someone was helped by our response?

[stetwood]

Crowe wrote:
Don't care. If they've taken my advice, that's fine. If not, it must not have been what they needed or wanted to hear. Sure, being polite is nice but if they don't say "thank you" it doesn't change my opinion of them.

And maybe as importantly is that the OP posted his question in a courteous manner and certainly after doing a search of the many hundreds of thousands of threads and the many years of postings to find an answer similar to what they were looking for.

[Crowe]

Don't care. If they've taken my advice, that's fine. If not, it must not have been what they needed or wanted to hear. Sure, being polite is nice but if they don't say "thank you" it doesn't change my opinion of them.

[MFL]

RoyB wrote:
I always change my POST TITTLE showing problem resolved when I have asked a question and resolved my problem...

I too usually get responce VIA PM when my comments helped someone... I mention the PM in my profile - maybe that is what triggers that???

Roy Ken

I just wanted to mention a possible reason for you getting more response, and thank you PMs. In the time I've been on this forum, I can't help but notice, that you are not only a knowledgeable person, but a genuine good fellow, never sarcastic, or demeaning to anyone!

Everyone appreciates people like you!

Jerry

[DutchmenSport]

beemerphile1 wrote:

Vet Man wrote:

...wouldn't it be nice if when we answer some ones questions and take our time to do it, if they came back to tell us how they made out...

I agree and while we are discussing things that are annoying, you know what annoys me? Vague thread titles that have no real meaning. An example would be "Would you like".

Good one! I laughed so hard at this I almost wet my pants! :B

[westend]

An old wise guy once told me, "There are two different kinds of people in the world, there are givers and there are takers".

[scbwr]

Yes, the polite thing to do is to at least respond. But, we have an awful large neighborhood here on the forums, and not everyone has been taught or learned how to be polite. And, there are a fair number of folks that respond in a rather rude fashion even though at times, it may not be intentional.

If you're really sensitive to other's comments, forums are not a great place to hang out!

[FlatBroke]

I love it when a new member posts what a piece of junk their brand newXXXXX is then you never hear another word out of them.

[robsouth]

Often, I will see a "newbie" ask a question at, say 1:00 PM. Status shows "online". I will see a response at, say 1:05 PM. OP's status shows "offline" and sometimes never to come back. I wonder if they forget about their post, or how they got to the forums in the first place. It's a mystery.

[beemerphile1]

Vet Man wrote:

...wouldn't it be nice if when we answer some ones questions and take our time to do it, if they came back to tell us how they made out...

I agree and while we are discussing things that are annoying, you know what annoys me? Vague thread titles that have no real meaning. An example would be "Would you like".