Mar-10-2016 02:00 PM
Mar-22-2016 01:27 AM
Mar-21-2016 10:07 PM
Mar-21-2016 07:57 PM
4X4Dodger wrote:rjstractor wrote:4x4Dodger wrote:
On a horsepower or torque/per loaded-pound basis the new GAS engines are close to what a class 8 deisel tractor has...the new diesel pickups are actually higher if measured that way.
That's an odd statement. Big trucks have far less hp and torque per loaded pound than pickups. They are moving 100K+ pounds with around 500 hp and 2000 ft./lbs of torque. That's the equivalent of moving 20K combined with just 100 hp and 400 ft./lbs of torque. That's why the heavily loaded semis crawl up mountain passes at 20-25 mph.
First the maximum load for a tractor trailer in MOST states is 80k# very few states allow trucks to weigh more than that.
Second most class 8's have around 800-900 lb/ft of torque not 2000
Third many are 450 to 550 hp.
It's not an odd statement at all in fact it was my point: The current crop of diesel p/u's have more horsepower and torque on a per loaded pound basis than the class 8's.
The horsepower/torque race among the big three p/u makers is just so much marketing hype. Sooner or later it will have to give way to higher efficiency diesels/Gas engines with less HP but overall better performance. this is what has happened with the class 8 engine builders.
Mar-21-2016 07:54 PM
Mar-21-2016 06:11 PM
transamz9 wrote:4X4Dodger wrote:transamz9 wrote:4X4Dodger wrote:
For the OP: Congratulations on your new truck. I too have the Gas Ram and I cannot imagine the diesel towing any better in real terms than this truck does. (I often pass the diesels on long upgrades with similar sized trailers)
I passed a Corvette the other day towing with my old Ford 6.0 Powerstroke so my truck must be faster right? LOL I'll be close to you next weekend if you would like to come hook to my 20,000# rig with you gas truck.
You are doing what so many do in these discussions; try to derail them into shouting matches with spurious comparisons and a snarky tone.
First I clearly said in my post that I passed on long uphills and steep grades diesels that were hauling SIMILAR sized trailers to mine. These trucks were clearly at the end of their power curve and I had to pass them or get stuck behind them going much more slowly than necessary or desirable.
My truck and trailer weighs in at over 16,000 lbs.
Your Corvette analogy is just silly.
The new gas engines and transmissions are fast closing the Gas/Deisel gap when transmissions were 3 or 4 speeds and you needed a 4:10 rearend to compensate. Those days are gone.
On a horsepower or torque/per loaded-pound basis the new GAS engines are close to what a class 8 deisel tractor has...the new diesel pickups are actually higher if measured that way.
Most guys I believe have a diesel because they WANT one not because they need one...and that's ok.
Diesels have their place, their advantages and disadvantages.
And indeed my 5.7 could tow your trailer. It would take more RPM's to get it started from a stop, more fuel and it would not pull your trailer as easily as it pulls mine ...but it would pull it.
So let me get this straight. You say your truck and trailer together weighs 16,000? You are saying that you would have to pass me if I was pulling a 9000# trailer because it would be obvious that I would be at the end of my powerband because I was going slower than you wanted to go. Haha. Thanks for the laugh.
Mar-21-2016 06:06 PM
rjstractor wrote:4x4Dodger wrote:
On a horsepower or torque/per loaded-pound basis the new GAS engines are close to what a class 8 deisel tractor has...the new diesel pickups are actually higher if measured that way.
That's an odd statement. Big trucks have far less hp and torque per loaded pound than pickups. They are moving 100K+ pounds with around 500 hp and 2000 ft./lbs of torque. That's the equivalent of moving 20K combined with just 100 hp and 400 ft./lbs of torque. That's why the heavily loaded semis crawl up mountain passes at 20-25 mph.
Mar-21-2016 05:55 PM
Grit dog wrote:
Ok you got the fastest gasser west of the Mississippi! We get it. Prolly blow the doors off my diesel up the Ike....
Mar-20-2016 05:22 PM
4X4Dodger wrote:transamz9 wrote:4X4Dodger wrote:
For the OP: Congratulations on your new truck. I too have the Gas Ram and I cannot imagine the diesel towing any better in real terms than this truck does. (I often pass the diesels on long upgrades with similar sized trailers)
I passed a Corvette the other day towing with my old Ford 6.0 Powerstroke so my truck must be faster right? LOL I'll be close to you next weekend if you would like to come hook to my 20,000# rig with you gas truck.
You are doing what so many do in these discussions; try to derail them into shouting matches with spurious comparisons and a snarky tone.
First I clearly said in my post that I passed on long uphills and steep grades diesels that were hauling SIMILAR sized trailers to mine. These trucks were clearly at the end of their power curve and I had to pass them or get stuck behind them going much more slowly than necessary or desirable.
My truck and trailer weighs in at over 16,000 lbs.
Your Corvette analogy is just silly.
The new gas engines and transmissions are fast closing the Gas/Deisel gap when transmissions were 3 or 4 speeds and you needed a 4:10 rearend to compensate. Those days are gone.
On a horsepower or torque/per loaded-pound basis the new GAS engines are close to what a class 8 deisel tractor has...the new diesel pickups are actually higher if measured that way.
Most guys I believe have a diesel because they WANT one not because they need one...and that's ok.
Diesels have their place, their advantages and disadvantages.
And indeed my 5.7 could tow your trailer. It would take more RPM's to get it started from a stop, more fuel and it would not pull your trailer as easily as it pulls mine ...but it would pull it.
Mar-20-2016 02:36 PM
Grit dog wrote:
Ok you got the fastest gasser west of the Mississippi! We get it. Prolly blow the doors off my diesel up the Ike....
Mar-20-2016 01:59 PM
4x4Dodger wrote:
On a horsepower or torque/per loaded-pound basis the new GAS engines are close to what a class 8 deisel tractor has...the new diesel pickups are actually higher if measured that way.
Mar-20-2016 09:39 AM
Mar-20-2016 08:09 AM
transamz9 wrote:4X4Dodger wrote:
For the OP: Congratulations on your new truck. I too have the Gas Ram and I cannot imagine the diesel towing any better in real terms than this truck does. (I often pass the diesels on long upgrades with similar sized trailers)
I passed a Corvette the other day towing with my old Ford 6.0 Powerstroke so my truck must be faster right? LOL I'll be close to you next weekend if you would like to come hook to my 20,000# rig with you gas truck.
Mar-19-2016 08:03 PM
Mar-19-2016 04:56 PM
4X4Dodger wrote:
For the OP: Congratulations on your new truck. I too have the Gas Ram and I cannot imagine the diesel towing any better in real terms than this truck does. (I often pass the diesels on long upgrades with similar sized trailers)