mike-s wrote:
Gdetrailer wrote:
mike-s wrote:
Some states require breakaways, others don't. There's no federal (DOT) requirement, at least for non-commercial trailers.
OK..
Perhaps you care to point out the EXACT Federal regulation that says this?
You were close, but wrong.
ยง 393.1: Scope of the rules in this part.
(a) The rules in this part establish minimum standards for commercial motor vehicles as defined in ยง 390.5 of this title. Only motor vehicles (as defined in ยง 390.5) and combinations of motor vehicles which meet the definition of a commercial motor vehicle are subject to the requirements of this part.
ALL states must follow the Federal regulations as a MINIMUM REQUIREMENT.
However, it is left up to the states if they wish to EXCEED the Federal requirements AND MOST DO EXCEED the Federal minimum standards.
However, SOME states simply adopted the Federal language pretty much untouched leaving some open interpretation for local Authorities.
Under PA requirements RECREATIONAL (IE RV) and Utility trailers FALLS UNDER "SEMI TRAILER" rules when it comes to trailer brakes and emergency break away systems..
See
HERE For PA requirements.
Note the areas I bolded..
"Subchapter G. RECREATIONAL, SEMI AND UTILITY TRAILERS
This subchapter cited in 67 Pa. Code ยง 175.202 (relating to conditions); 67 Pa. Code ยง 175.204 (relating to tires); and 67 Pa. Code ยง 175.209 (relating to chassis).
ยง 175.121. Application.
Equipment standards set forth in this subchapter apply to trailers towed or operated on highways.
Source
The provisions of this ยง 175.121 adopted December 2, 1977, effective February 1, 1978, 7 Pa.B. 3499; readopted December 2, 1988, effective December 3, 1988, 18 Pa.B. 5362. Immediately preceding text appears at serial page (101015).
ยง 175.123. Braking systems.
(a) Condition of braking systems. Braking systems and components shall be in safe operating condition as described in ยง 175.130 (relating to inspection procedure).
(b) Service brakes. A trailer shall be equipped with a service brake system. See 75 Pa.C.S. ยง 4502 (relating to general requirements for braking systems).
(1) The service brakes shall act on all wheels upon application except for the following:
(i) On interconnected dual wheels, the brakes may act upon only one wheel.
(ii) A vehicle being towed in driveaway-towaway operation.
(iii) A trailer of a gross weight not exceeding 3,000 pounds, if the gross weight of the trailer does not exceed 40% of the gross weight of the towing vehicle.
(2) The service brakes, when required, shall be capable of stopping the vehicle in not more than the maximum stopping distance prescribed in Table I.
(3) Surge or inertia type brake systems are authorized.
(4) The brake lining and brake fluids shall be of a type approved by the vehicle manufacturer or shall meet the Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) standards (J998, January 1980)โsee Appendix A (relating to minimum requirements for motor vehicle brake liningsโSAE J998).
(5) Metal from the shoe may not contact the brake drums or rotors.
(6) A vehicle to which additional axles and wheels have been added shall be equipped with brakes on the additional wheels.
(7) Brake lines shall be approved for use as brake lines.
(c) Breakaway system. A trailer operated on a highway which is equipped with brakes or which has gross weight in excess of 3,000 pounds shall be equipped with a breakaway system which shall stop and hold the vehicle automatically upon breakaway from the towing vehicle.
(d) Air chamber push rod. The air chamber push rod travel may not exceed the manufacturerโs specifications maximum stroke allowance. See Chart 4 (relating to brake chamber push rod travel (typical)) for a drawing of the air chamber push rod.
Authority
The provisions of this ยง 175.123 amended under the Vehicle Code, 75 Pa.C.S. ยง ยง 4103, 4301, 4501, 4521 and 6103.
Source
The provisions of this ยง 175.123 adopted December 2, 1977, effective February 1, 1978, 7 Pa.B. 3499; amended October 29, 1982, effective February 1, 1983, 12 Pa.B. 3862; corrected November 12, 1982, effective February 1, 1983, 12 Pa.B. 3947; readopted December 2, 1988, effective December 3, 1988, 18 Pa.B. 5362; amended November 13, 1998, effective May 13, 1999, 28 Pa.B. 5670. Immediately preceding text appears at serial pages (221278) to (221279). I CAN assure you EVERY STATE WILL REQUIRE A WORKING BREAKAWAY SYSTEM IF THE TRAILER HAS BEEN EQUIPPED WITH BRAKES!
In PA, a non working breakaway system means your trailer WILL FAIL the state inspection. Fail the inspection and you CANNOT move the trailer on public roads, period.
Telling folks that a breakaway system is not required to be functional is just plain stupid. The breakaway system IS for yours and other motorists protection, has nothing to do with saving your trailer but saving LIVES.
Many years ago there was nearly an entire FAMILY KILLED when a chipper broke loose from a truck.. The chipper smashed into the van..
The chipper was improperly secured and had no brakes or breakaway system.
The driver was sentenced 9 to 18 months, max he could have gotten was 17yrs in prison and was ordered to keep a photo of the accident scene at his home!
HERE is news story..
"PITTSBURGH (AP) - A truck driver who improperly hitched a wood-chipper to his vehicle was sentenced Tuesday to nine to 18 months in jail for causing a crash that killed a Beaver Area Middle School teacher and two of his triplets. He also was ordered to keep a picture of the accident scene at his home.
The wood-chipper broke free from Bradley Demitras' truck on a busy highway, rolled across the median and slammed into the family's minivan.
Demitras, 35, of Pine Township, had faced a maximum sentence of up more than 17 years in prison. He pleaded guilty in March to three counts of involuntary manslaughter and other charges, and acknowledged that the wood-chipper wasn't properly hooked up to his truck before he left work on April 13, 2006.
Prosecutors said Demitras was speeding on Route 8 just north of Pittsburgh when the wood-chipper flew into the opposing lanes, killing Spencer Morrison, 37, of Cranberry Township and his 4-year-olds, Alaina and Garrett.
Demitras also pleaded guilty to one count of reckless endangerment for critically injuring the third triplet, Ethan, and several lesser traffic citations.
Demitras' sentence also includes six years' probation and a requirement that he prominently display the accident-scene photo in his home. He apologized in court Tuesday.
"All I can say is I am sorry," Demitras said. "I know that sounds like the hollowest thing in the world, but I am sorry."
Allegheny County Judge Lester Nauhaus said imposing the sentence was "the worst decision I've ever had to make" in 40 years as a judge, attorney and public defender.
"I don't think you need to be punished to the maximum period," Nauhaus said. "I just think you need to be punished."
Morrison was a middle school social studies teacher in the Beaver Area School District. He began teaching in the district in 1993 and was the high school football team's equipment manager and an assistant baseball coach. Morrison himself was a baseball player when he attended Clarion University.
After the fatal accident, Beaver Area School District Superintendent John Hansen said young people were Morrison's passion, and Morrison was very dedicated to his family.
Times Staff Writer Kristen Garrett contributed to this story."If a 3K lb chipper can KILL a family just that easy what do you think the odds of someone living after a 5K-10K lb trailer hits their vehicle?
Doesn't matter if it is a semi trailer or RV trailer, weight is weight and it CAN KILL.
The whole point of breakaway systems is to control and stop a runaway trailer.